No. Going back on everyone is a habit from the early days of the platform and it’s a net loss. You end up with a timeline you don’t look at, a following figure which tells you absolutely nothing about your actual taste and a following that came for the trade and will go when the trade suits them.
That’s the position of the article and the rest of it goes on to explain why. There is one scenario in which following back en masse absolutely does make sense and that’s covered right at the end.
| For following everyone back | Against |
|---|---|
| It is polite and takes one tap | A reply acknowledges a follower better |
| Some people unfollow if you do not | Those followers came for the exchange |
| A new account feels less empty | The timeline fills with posts you skip |
| It looks approachable | Your public following list stops saying anything about you |
The case for following everyone back
The argument absolutely deserves to be heard. A ‘follow back’ is perfectly polite, it’s one tap and some people will unfollow if it’s not reciprocated. For a very new account a few mutual follows can go a long way to making the account feel less barren. Those who follow back will also say it’s a sign that you’re approachable.
Why it does not hold up
Politeness on X is demonstrated via replies and a follow is a very weak form of acknowledgement. If you want to acknowledge a new follower then answering one of their posts does far more than a follow you’ll never act on.
The timeline is the real cost. Every account you follow gets its posts into the feed and attention is finite. If you follow 2000 accounts out of a sense of obligation then the 200 you actually care about are completely buried.
Then there’s the whole issue of who you’re attracting. The accounts that follow you in order to be followed are the ones that are counting and they’re not really reading. A lot of them will unfollow a few days later regardless of whether you’ve responded or not. You end up with a follower list that looks big but in reality it’s not very active.
Your list is also public. People look at it to work out what kind of account you are. A list of people you’ve chosen tells them something. A list of everyone who has ever followed you tells them absolutely nothing.
What X’s own rules say
X limits the rate at which you can follow and the total number of accounts you can follow. Each account is limited to 400 follows per day and once you’ve hit 5,000 follows your ability to follow further is dependent on the ratio of your followers to the number of accounts you’re following. X also has the concept of ‘follow churn’ which is the act of following and unfollowing a large number of accounts and this is deemed to be behaviour which can get you locked. None of this stops you from following back. It just shows that X will contain mass following.
| Rule | Figure |
|---|---|
| Follows per day, every account | Up to 400 |
| Point where ratio limits begin | 5,000 accounts followed |
| Follow churn | Prohibited |
A better rule
Follow back if you would have followed anyway. Have a look at the last few posts. If you’d be happy to see them tomorrow then follow. If you’re not sure then just wait as there’s nothing to be lost by making the decision next week.
The exception
Follow back liberally if the person you’re following is someone you already have some kind of relationship with (a customer, a colleague, a member of a small local community etc). In that case the follow back is part of an existing relationship that predates the app and a List can be used to keep those accounts together if your main timeline becomes too full.
From our archive: let the followers discover you.
Questions readers ask
Will I lose followers if I stop following back?
A few, and largely the ones who are there for the exchange. The people who are there because of what you post aren’t keeping score.
Should I unfollow accounts that I followed in the past?
You can, gradually. Strip out a few dormant or irrelevant accounts each week and you’ll be well clear of any appearance of churn.
Does following back help my posts get seen?
There’s no rule that rewards it. What helps is having followers who engage with your posts and those are earned through your posts.
